California Sues H&R Block over “Instant” Tax Refunds

California’s Attorney General, Bill Lockyer, filed a suit in San Francisco last week alleging that H&R Block and participating lenders have deceived the tax preparation company’s clients by failing to disclose the true costs of “Instant” refund anticipation loans. The loans are short-term advances of federal income tax refunds, minus fees and interest, that give customers immediate access to their money. The lender who provides the advances – HSBC Bank - collects the borrower’s actual Internal Revenue Service (IRS) refund check as the loan repayment. Block doesn’t make the loans; the firm collects a fee for processing the loan paperwork, the Sacramento Bee reports.


Advertisement


Easy & Profitable Client Payroll with PayCycle

Now is a great time to get clients set up for payroll. We’d like to invite you to a FREE 60-minute web seminar sponsored by PayCycle, the leader in on-demand payroll. During this informative session, you’ll discover how to:

  1. Automate payroll tasks from paychecks to W-2’s
  2. Save time with electronic tax payments and filings
  3. Increase year-round firm profitability without adding staff or infrastructure

Come see for yourself how easy and profitable payroll can be - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER Hurry! Spaces are limited and the sessions fill up quickly.

All PayCycle webinar attendees will receive 1 month free on PayCycle’s service. After the free period, PayCycle costs just $14.99 per client per month for the first 5 employees. Each additional employee is just $0.25 per month. This low monthly fee includes everything you need to process payroll, including a firm-branded website for clients, direct deposit, electronic tax payments and filings, seamless integration with QuickBooks, ATX, CCH and other leading accounting software, free customer support with payroll experts, customized marketing resources to solicit your payroll service to clients, and much more.

Learn More Register for a Web Seminar Sign Up Now


Interest rates charged on the loans could run as high as 100 percent over the course of a year, the suit alleges. “In marketing and selling these expensive loans, H&R Block has profited greatly, but deceived customers, violated their privacy rights and taken money from California families who can least afford it,” Lockyer said.

H&R Block has sold more that 1.5 million refund anticipation loans in California since 2001, Tom Dressler, a spokesman for the attorney general, said in a Reuters report, and about 70 percent of the loans went to low-income families. The California suit seeks compensation for H&R Block clients and a $20 million fine.

H&R Block said it would fight the suit. Spokesperson Linda McDougall said that H&R Block charged the same tax preparation fees for everyone, based on the complexity of the returns. Interest expenses on the loans are paid when the IRS issues the refund, she said, the Sacramento Bee reported, usually within two weeks if the return is filed electronically,.

The suit lacks merit, H&R Block claims in a press release, because it focuses on the cross-collection practices of the lender, which are governed by federal and not state laws. The suit alleges that Block does not tell clients that any previous years’ unpaid refund fees may be deducted, along with current fees, kansascity.com says.

Defending its procedures in the press release the company says, “Client disclosures go into great detail to describe other, lower-cost tax filing options, explain the cost of the loans, and advise clients that cross collection would occur on such prior debts. The word “loan” appears on each page of the bank’s loan application in letters two inches high, and also is very clearly used in all of the product’s advertising.”

Block settled four class-action lawsuits over the loans in December by agreeing to pay $62.5 million.

You may like these other stories...

With tax season in the past, it's time to think about the tax implications of decisions your clients may be making about their homes in 2014. The rules are complicated and because of the huge amounts involved, the...
IRS revokes group’s tax exemption over anti-Clinton statementsGregory Korte of the USA Today reported on Monday that the IRS has revoked the tax-exempt status of a conservative-aligned charity, the Patrick Henry Center...
Clawback policies vary by company, industry: PwCAccording to a report issued to clients by PwC on April 17, companies have instituted a wide range of so-called clawback policies – with no two exactly alike – in...

Upcoming CPE Webinars

Apr 24
In this session Excel expert David Ringstrom, CPA introduces you to a powerful but underutilized macro feature in Excel.
Apr 25
This material focuses on the principles of accounting for non-profit organizations' revenues. It will include discussions of revenue recognition for cash and non-cash contributions as well as other revenues commonly received by non-profit organizations.
Apr 30
During the second session of a four-part series on Individual Leadership, the focus will be on time management- a critical success factor for effective leadership. Each person has 24 hours of time to spend each day; the key is making wise investments and knowing what investments yield the greatest return.
May 1
This material focuses on the principles of accounting for non-profit organizations’ expenses. It will include discussions of functional expense categories, accounting for functional expenses and allocations of joint costs.