Both President Trump and the Republican leaders in Congress have advocated a repeal of the federal estate tax. If that occurs, certain tax concerns facing wealthy families would be wiped away, perhaps forever.
But a repeal, if one is indeed enacted, could come with some strings attached, especially with regard to income taxes. In fact, some families may wind up in worse overall tax shape than before.
The federal estate tax has traveled a circuitous route to this point since its inception in 1916. At the turn of the century, the top estate tax rate had reached a hefty 55 percent, while the unified estate and gift tax exemption could effectively shield assets valued at up to $675,000. After the exemption was hiked to $1 million, Congress enacted the Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act (EGTRRA) of 2001. And that’s when the fun really began.
Under EGTRRA, the top tax rate was gradually lowered over the ensuing decade from 55 percent to 45 percent, while the exemption climbed from $1 million to $3.5 million. Along the way, the unified estate and gift tax systems were severed, along with other significant changes. And then EGTRRA repealed the estate tax completely, but for just one year – 2010 – before it was immediately reinstated in 2011.
Subsequent legislation imposed a top estate tax rate of 40 percent with a $5 million exemption, indexed for inflation ($5.49 million in 2017), and reunified the estate and gift tax systems.
The latest changes were supposed to be “permanent.” But now the Trump administration is pushing for an outright repeal of the tax. It’s not clear if the gift tax would also be abolished, and that might be a bargaining chip in negotiations. Perhaps even more important, however, would be the provisions relating to the “step-up in basis” for income tax purposes.
Content seriesView full content series
Currently, when a decedent dies, the basis in the inherited assets is stepped up to the value of the assets on the date of death, as opposed to a prior regime where the decedent’s basis was carried over. Because of the step-up in basis, the appreciation in value while the decedent owned the assets is never taxed. If an heir sells the assets immediately after inheriting them, it’s likely there will be little or no income tax consequences.