A client of mine was providing services to various businesses through her own Ltd company (she was the sole shareholder and sole director). She recently decided to stop trading and the balance sheet shows £5k of VAT owed to HMRC. There is no cash in the Ltd company to pay HMRC as her director account is overdrawn by a similar amount (i.e. she's also the company's sole debtor).
She was advised by a previous accountant to allow HMRC to force the company into liquidation as it has no assets (other than her debtor balance) and so there's nothing for them to take - apparently for £5k they'll 'let it go' and won't pursue her for the debt she owes the business.
I wondered if anyone had experience of this in practice, particular where the company owes a small amount (e.g. less than £10k). It doesn't sit right with me as she has the means to repay the debt to the company, which would allow it to settle with HMRC. I'd be more inclined to suggest a payment plan with HMRC to settle what they're owed.
She has no further use for this company and is leaving the industry she's in altogether. She is likely to start trading in a new industry and may want to start a new Ltd company, and so doesn't want anything to show on her record that would affect her reputation (e.g. to become a disqualified director) or ability to run a company in a new industry.
Does anyone have any experience in how HMRC are likely to deal with this in practice. Are they likely to simply 'let it go' on the basis there are no tangible assets for them to take posession of? If so could this result in her becoming a disqualified director.
I basically need to know if I would be giving her bad advice by advising to repay the debt to the company and paying HMRC - could she really get off scot-free?