Enron Reopens Pandora's Box of Tax-Audit Conflicts

Last month, as the post-Enron audit-reform talks escalated, Bernard Wolfman warned Harvey Pitt, chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), that a Pandora's box of potential conflicts of interest can arise when an accounting firm provides tax products or advice to an audit client.

Bernard Wolfman is the Fessenden Professor of Law at Harvard Law School and one of the nation’s foremost experts on legal ethics in tax practice. This is not the first time Professor Wolfman has spoken out on this controversial and multi-faceted subject. But this time, he received a cordial reply from Robert Burns, chief counsel to SEC's Office of the Chief Accountant. Mr. Burns said the SEC will carefully consider Professor Wolfman’s input as it turns Chairman Pitt’s audit reform plans into a comprehensive and detailed proposal.

Potential Tax-Audit Conflicts

"There are broad and pervasive issues that the SEC needs to deal with," explains Professor Wolfman. In the letter he sent to the SEC, he outlined three hypothetical cases for further study. All three involve a CPA firm (Audit LLP) whose professionals are all CPAs and none are also lawyers.

  • Case 1. Audit LLP provides the attest function for corporate client A. It sells a tax product to A for a flat sum of $100,000, telling A the product should save it $1 million in federal income taxes over four years.
  • Case 2. Audit LLP provides the attest function for corporate client B. It advises B to write off $2 million of expenditures, although it recognizes that if B is audited by the IRS, the write-off will be disallowed and the expenditures capitalized as a result of the Supreme Court’s holding in the INDOPCO case.
  • Case 3. Audit LLP provides the attest function to corporate client C and also advises client C on tax matters. Without consulting Audit, C purchases a tax product from another tax product huckster. The product is similar but not identical to the one Audit sold to A.

Do any of these cases present a conflict of interest for Audit LLP? Professor Wolfman believes a case can be made for answering "yes" to all three, if the taxes involved are material. The reasoning: In order to issue an audit opinion, the auditors must use their judgment regarding the accuracy of their client's reserve for taxes, and the facts in all three cases are likely to raise suspicions that Audit's tax role has affected its judgment.

The Case for Complete Separation of Audit and Tax Services

One possible fix suggested by others is to bar auditors from providing tax planning services to their clients. In fact, the SEC considered that solution when it drafted its auditor independence rules two years ago. But Professor Wolfman points out that in Case C, even this seemingly draconian measure would not suffice to prevent all potential conflicts of interests. The only totally effective solution, explains Professor Wolfman, is to provide for a complete separation of duties in which audit firms would not be permitted to provide tax products or tax consultative services at all.

Taking this line of reasoning to its logical conclusion, Professor Wolfman says, "Auditors should offer only the vital auditing service, and tax services should be provided by tax consultants -- lawyers or CPAs (whether or not also lawyers) -- who are not engaged in providing the attest function to anyone."

Related links
Could Enron Collapse Lead to Big Five Losing Tax Work?

-Rosemary Schlank

You may like these other stories...

Starting in January 2015, the IRS will limit the number of refunds that are electronically deposited into a single financial account or pre-paid debit card to three, as part of the agency’s effort to crack down on...
House proposes $10.5B, eight-month highway billThe House Ways and Means Committee proposed a transportation funding bill on Tuesday that calls for a temporary extension of current transportation funding levels until May 31,...
Swiss banks threaten freeze on US accounts over tax evasionJames Shotter of the Financial Times reported on Monday that several Swiss banks have threatened to freeze American clients’ accounts unless they prove they...

Upcoming CPE Webinars

Jul 16
Hand off work to others with finesse and success. Kristen Rampe, CPA will share how to ensure delegated work is properly handled from start to finish in this content-rich one hour webinar.
Jul 17
This webcast will cover the preparation of the statement of cash flows and focus on accounting and disclosure policies for other important issues described below.
Jul 23
We can’t deny a great divide exists between the expectations and workplace needs of Baby Boomers and Millennials. To create thriving organizational performance, we need to shift the way in which we groom future leaders.
Jul 24
In this presentation Excel expert David Ringstrom, CPA revisits the Excel feature you should be using, but probably aren't. The Table feature offers the ability to both boost the integrity of your spreadsheets, but reduce maintenance as well.