SEC, Justice Department Support PCAOB Constitutionality

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the U.S. Department of Justice (DoJ) have expressed support for the constitutionality of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB).


Thousands of executives with financial reporting responsibilities use the Comperio on-line library to access the type of information and interpretive guidance PricewaterhouseCoopers' own professional audit staff use around the world. Key content areas include guidance from the FASB, EITF, PCAOB, SEC, and others as well as PwC's interpretive guidance. Get more information and sign up for a complimentary 30-day trial.

With the filing of a legal brief just before Labor Day, the SEC and Justice Department disputed the Free Enterprise Fund, a conservative think tank, which argued in a February lawsuit that the PCAOB’s structure violates both the appointments clause and the separation of powers principles of the U.S. Constitution. A small Nevada accounting firm, Beckstead & Watts, joined the suit.

Plaintiffs say PCAOB members are “principal” officers who must be appointed by the president, not the SEC; alternatively, the plaintiffs argue that if the board members are considered to be “inferior” officers, the SEC does not conform to “heads of departments” as laid out in the appointments clause. The complaint also says that PCAOB members are removable by the president, and therefore authority that is reserved for the executive branch is removed.

The PCAOB was created under the Sarbanes-Oxley (SOX) corporate reform legislation of 2002. The SEC unanimously selects PCAOB members and oversees the board, which in turn oversees the accounting industry. The PCAOB registers and inspects public accounting firms, issues auditing standards, and disciplines firms.

The government’s brief (, filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, argues that SEC's “pervasive oversight authority leaves no doubt of the existence of a ‘superior/inferior’ relationship for purposes of the appointments cause…”

It went on to say, “Plaintiffs similarly err in urging that the SEC should be treated as a headless non-department. In many crucial respects, the SEC functions analogously to a Cabinet-level agency, and neither the text nor the purpose of the appointments clause requires that appointments be made by an individual head rather than by the governing commissioners as a body.”

It also said that the president himself does not have the sole power to remove PCAOB members. “The general rule has long been that such officials are removable by the same subordinate officials who appointed them…” The brief further rejects the separation of powers concerns, saying that Sarbanes-Oxley “plainly does not undermine the powers of the Executive Branch or disrupt the proper balance between the coordinate branches.”

You may like these other stories...

Companies are taking their time transitioning to the 2013 Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) Internal Control-Integrated Framework, even though the updated guidance is set to take effect...
By Jason BramwellOfficials from the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) said on August 19 that deficiencies were found in all sixty of the broker-dealer audits conducted by audit firms that the PCAOB inspected...
By Frank Byrt and Anne RosivachThe Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) issued a cautiously optimistic report on US auditors' performance, saying the Board found a reduced rate of "significant audit...

Already a member? log in here.

Upcoming CPE Webinars

Oct 30Many Excel users have a love-hate relationship with workbook links.
Nov 5Join CPA thought leader and peer reviewer Rob Cameron and learn ways to improve the outcome of your peer reviews while maximizing the value of your engagement workflow.
Nov 12This webcast presents basic principles of revenue recognition, including new ASU 2014-09 for the contract method. Also, CPAs in industries who want a refresher on revenue accounting standards will benefit.
Nov 18In this session Excel expert David Ringstrom, CPA tackles what to do when bad things happen to good spreadsheets.