Mental Accounting: How to Justify Spending That Can't Be Justified

We've all done it: Convinced ourselves that our tax refund is really “free money” and therefore can be spent on a big-screen TV, vacation or fancy dinners.

Call it “intaxication,” defined by one clever Washington Post reader as “euphoria at getting a tax refund, which lasts until you realize it was your money to start with.”

Intaxication may not be a real word, but the phenomenon is. A new study shows that taxpayers can easily justify spending what is actually part of their salary on things they don't need.

Amar Cheema, an assistant professor of marketing in the Olin School of Business at Washington University in St. Louis, says many people keep “mental accounts” of their money to control spending. But that mental accounting can get fairly creative – at tax refund time and at the holidays, for example – making it easy to overspend.

To compensate for buying too much, consumers invoke an “un-incurred” cost, Cheema says, such as not signing up for a cable TV service that would have cost $400 a year.

“Consumers are motivated to define expenses and shape mental accounts in a way that allows them to do what they want to do rather than what they should do,” Cheema said in a statement. “Our research identifies loopholes that people exploit so they can do what they should not do–overspend, incur debt… in sum, make poor decisions.”

Cheema and University of Toronto professor Dilip Soman explain the concept in their paper, "Malleable Mental Accounting: How Individuals Manipulate Mental Accounts to Justify Attractive Consumption and Spending Decisions."

Cheema explains that most people create two kinds of mental accounts – budgetary accounts for food, housing and entertainment, for example – and transaction-specific accounts, for occasional purchases like a refrigerator or opera tickets.

Problems crop up when consumers don't know how to categorize a purchase. And when the tax refund arrives in the mail, mental accounting gets pretty flexible.

"Let's say I have wanted to go on a vacation to Miami for a while, and I may apply this refund money to my 'vacation' budgetary account to justify taking that vacation, which is what I want to do, rather than paying off some of my mortgage, as I should do," Cheema says. "In doing so I exploit the ambiguity associated with the purpose of the account, and find a way to spend on luxuries that I was trying to otherwise control."

How can consumers control spending? Cheema says people should draw definite boundaries and clear definitions of spending categories. Unjustified spending also occurs less often if you must be accountable to someone else. So if you're thinking about spending the tax refund on that Miami trip, tell your spouse - you may realign your priorities.

Voice of the Editor

What would you do if one of your clients won the lottery? We asked several accountants to weigh in with their advice for the lucky Powerball winner, and the tips we received are useful for anyone who receives a windfall, whether it's a lottery win, an inheritance, a big bonus on the job, or a killing in the stock market.
ADVERTISEMENT

This Week on AccountingWEB

CPAs Mira Finé, Scott Hitchcock, Rob Keasal, Kathy Scorcio, and Ken Travis offer ten pieces of financial advice for the newest Powerball winner.
Hang Bower of BDO USA and Dan Black of Ernst & Young share their perspectives on why their firms made the Best Places to Work for Recent Grads 2013 list.
Herbein + Company, Inc. firm members talked with AccountingWEB about their year-round employee wellness program.
Bill Walter of Gross, Mendelsohn & Associates and Harold Gaar of TravisWolff LLP weigh in on mobile technology use while employees are at work.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT