SEC Fines EY, More Auditor Independence Cases to Come

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) fined an overseas office of Ernst & Young (EY) $400,000 for lack of independence in the audits of Baan Company, N.V., a business software company headquartered in the Netherlands. An SEC official indicated that other auditor independence cases might soon follow.

The SEC charges that joint business relationships between Baan and EY's overseas office resulted in an impairment of auditor independence. The relationships were established to help EY consultants implement Baan's software products for third parties. They included a project subsidized by the Dutch government for the joint development of faster software implementation tools, as well as joint marketing activities emphasizing the "partnership" between Baan and EY, and Baan's use of EY consultants as subcontractors and temporary employees in servicing Baan's clients.

In some ways, the Baan case is similar to the independence violations alleged in the PeopleSoft case, which EY is contesting. Examples:

  • Both cases reach back a number of years. The Baan case involves audits of 1995, 1996, and 1997 financial statements. Since then, EY resigned as Baan's auditor in 1998, Baan was acquired by Invensys Plc in 2000, and EY's U.K. affiliate is now Invensys's auditor.

  • Commissioner Isaac Hunt was the only SEC commissioner to vote on both matters. Chairman Harvey Pitt and Commissioner Cynthia Glassman both recused themselves because they have past ties to Ernst & Young.

SEC Associate Enforcement Director Paul R. Berger told Bloomberg, "There may well be audit-independence cases coming down soon, including some involving the Big Four accounting firms." The Commission has already filed auditor independence charges against KPMG and PricewaterhouseCoopers. But neither of these firms was fined. The EY case is the first time an accounting firm was fined for an independence violation.

-Rosemary Schlank

You may like these other stories...

Here's a CPA who truly walks the walk. On March 15, Frank Ryan, CPA, departed San Diego, California, with plans to be in Ocean City, Maryland, by July 2 to teach a course at the Maryland Association of CPAs’ (MACPA...
When Theodore J. Flynn first joined the Massachusetts Society of CPAs (MSCPA) in 1970, it was a different world and a different profession.  The "Big Eight" were still headquartered in Boston. Vietnam War...
Accountant Rickey Charles Goodrich had it a little too good. Many bean counters would kill to serve as financial guru to the likes of Pearl Jam. Goodrich was hired in 2005, and the following year, he became the CFO of Curtis...

Upcoming CPE Webinars

Aug 5
This webcast will focus on accounting and disclosure policies for various types of consolidations and business combinations.
Aug 20
In this session we'll review best practices for how to generate interest in your firm’s services.
Aug 21
Meet budgets and client expectations using project management skills geared toward the unique challenges faced by CPAs. Kristen Rampe will share how knowing the keys to structuring and executing a successful project can make the difference between success and repeated failures.
Aug 28
Excel spreadsheets are often akin to the American Wild West, where users can input anything they want into any worksheet cell. Excel's Data Validation feature allows you to restrict user inputs to selected choices, but there are many nuances to the feature that often trip users up.