Grand Jury Investigating Ernst & Young Tax Shelter Sales | AccountingWEB

Grand Jury Investigating Ernst & Young Tax Shelter Sales

Federal investigators have launched a criminal investigation into Ernst & Young’s tax shelter practices, despite the $15 million settlement the firm reached on the matter last year with the Internal Revenue Service, the Wall Street Journal reported.

A grand jury has been impaneled and it is believed the investigation is in its earliest stages. Often charges do not result from grand jury investigations. A separate criminal probe is pending against fellow Big Four accounting firm KPMG LLP in regard to that firm’s tax shelter sales practices.

The shelters were promoted during the stock market heyday of the 1990s and it is believed they diverted tens of billions of dollars from Treasury coffers, the Journal reported.

"As we have done in other inquiries regarding tax shelters, we are cooperating fully with this investigation," Ernst spokesman Charles Perkins told the Journal, refusing to comment further. It is unclear how broad the investigation's scope is.

Earlier this year, Ernst was suspended by the SEC from accepting any new audit clients for six months. The unusually long suspension was the firm’s punishment for engaging in a lucrative business deal with audit client PeopleSoft, in violation of auditor independence rules, the Journal reported.

The industry were surprised by the Ernst & Young grand-jury investigation in light of the settlement last year reached between Ernst and the IRS, which had alleged Ernst had failed to comply with rules requiring that tax-shelter promoters register certain tax strategies with the government and maintain lists of investors who participate in them, the Journal reported. Ernst admitted to no wrongdoing as part of the settlement.

In testimony in October before a Senate committee investigating corporate tax shelters, IRS Commissioner Mark Everson singled out Ernst for praise, the Journal reported. "We are pleased that Ernst & Young has cooperated fully with the IRS in resolving these matters," he said at the hearing. "This represents a real breakthrough and is a good working model for agreements with practitioners."

Ed Ketz, an accounting professor at Pennsylvania State University, told the Journal he "cannot imagine" that the U.S. government would indict another accounting firm, due to concerns about the damage that could have on global financial markets, especially in the wake of the demise of Arthur Andersen. As for the latest development at Ernst, "It's another black eye for them," he said. "And the question for us is: How many more black eyes can they take before it has some serious impacts on their relationships with their clients?"

Wait, there's more!
There's always more at AccountingWEB. We're an active community of financial professionals and journalists who strive to bring you valuable content every day. If you'd like, let us know your interests and we'll send you a few articles every week either in taxation, practice excellence, or just our most popular stories from that week. It's free to sign up and to be a part of our community.
Premium content is currently locked

Editor's Choice

WHAT KIND OF FIRM ARE YOU?
As part of our continued effort to provide valuable resources and insight to our subscribers, we're conducting this brief survey to learn more about your personal experiences in the accounting profession. We will be giving away five $50 Amazon gift cards, and a $250 Amazon gift card to one lucky participant.
This is strictly for internal use and data will not be sold
or shared with any third parties.