Ernst & Young Sued For Its Computer Associates Audit

Dallas investor Sam Wyly has filed a lawsuit against Ernst & Young LLP, claiming that the firm's audit influenced him to sell his software company in exchange for stock in Computer Associates International Inc.

Ernst & Young was the auditor for both companies when Sterling Software Inc., which Wyly headed, was sold to Computer Associates for $4 billion in March 2000, the Wall Street Journal reported.

Wyly's suit said he depended on Ernst & Young's fiscal 1999 audit to make the decision to sell, but a month after the sale, Computer Associates' share price plummeted 12 percent in one day when the company delayed reporting its year-end earnings, the Journal reported. The stock dropped again later after Computer Associates' sales fell short of forecasts.

Ernst & Young "specifically supplied assurances as to the accuracy of CA's financials to Sterling Software and Sterling's Board and shareholders," the suit says.

In the end, a $2.2 billion accounting scandal engulfed Computer Associates, leading to the indictment of chief executive officer Sanjay Kumar and other executives.

Wyly wants $80 million or more from Ernst & Young, the suit says. Wyly also filed a lawsuit seeking five seats on Computer Associates' board in 2001, but he dropped the suit in 2002 after Computer Associates agreed to pay him $10 million and improve governance practices.

Voice of the Editor

Even though any accounting auditor would tell you it seems like there are an awful lot of tax accountants out there, surely one-third of the country isn't made up of tax preparers, so it's rather startling news to learn that one-third of Americans like to do their taxes. Who knew?
ADVERTISEMENT

This Week on AccountingWEB

Bill Walter of Gross, Mendelsohn & Associates and Harold Gaar of TravisWolff LLP weigh in on mobile technology use while employees are at work.
WestArk RSVP and Fayette County Community Action Agency – organizations that received grant funding through the IRS Tax Counseling for the Elderly (TCE) program – spoke with AccountingWEB about how they assist senior citizens in their communities.
CPA Robert Raiola, who heads the Sports & Entertainment Group of Fazio, Mannuzza, Roche, Tankel, LaPilusa, LLC, talks NFL player income taxes with AccountingWEB.
Retiring KPMG Centennial Professor of Accounting at the University of Texas at Austin McCombs School of Business Robert May, PhD talks with AccountingWEB about his rewarding forty-three-year career.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT