Andersen Raised Concerns About Enron a Year Ago | AccountingWEB

Andersen Raised Concerns About Enron a Year Ago

The Washington Post reports today that an internal Andersen e-mail message prompted top management to consider dropping Enron as a client as early as February 2001 because of concerns about bookkeeping irregularities.

According to sources, the e-mail message (available in PDF format here) was sent to two partners in the Houston office as well as other senior executives around the country, and expressed concerns about the possibility of damaging Andersen's reputation by keeping Enron as a client. It is not known who sent the e-mail message.

It is unclear whether the e-mail referred to ordinary reviews of client situations or if it was raising particular red flags about the Enron situation.

Andersen immediately issued a press release indicating that the review was "routine" and part of the normal process for reviewing client engagements.

Enron Insider Shared Concerns With Andersen in August 2001

Sherron Watkins, the Enron vice president who sent a seven-page letter to Enron CEO Kenneth Lay expressing her fear that Enron would "implode in a wave of accounting scandals," also discussed her concerns with a member of senior management at Arthur Andersen's Houston office on August 20, 2001.

Following the discussion with Ms. Watkins, a meeting of Andersen's top officials in Houston was convened. David B. Duncan, the lead Andersen auditor on the Enron engagement attended that meeting. Mr. Duncan was fired by Andersen on Tuesday for his participation in the destruction of perhaps thousands of documents relating to the Enron audit.

A memo was drafted at Andersen describing Ms. Watkins' concerns, but no action relating to those concerns appears to have been taken.

Andersen Auditor Testifies Before Congressional Committee

David B. Duncan, the Andersen auditor who was fired this week for his complicity in destroying documents relating to the Enron affair, testified Wednesday before the House Energy and Commerce Committee, one of six congressional committees investigating the Enron situation.

Mr. Duncan was questioned by committee investigators for several hours. Reports are that Mr. Duncan was cooperative in his testimony and did not request immunity from prosecution.

After speaking with Mr. Duncan, Ken Johnson, spokesman for the House Energy and Commerce Committee said, "It's now clear to us that key players at Andersen as well as Enron knew of the growing problems months before the company imploded."

Andersen CEO Speaks Out

Joe Berardino, Andersen's Managing Partner and CEO, placed full-page ads in several major publications on Wednesday, including The Wall Street Journal, wherein he described how Andersen is responding to the Enron situation.

You can read a copy of the letter.

Andersen Will Exceed Liability Insurance Limits

It is estimated that the liability insurance coverage for Big Five firm Andersen is probably in the $300 to $500 million range. It is also estimated that potential lawsuits stemming from the Enron collapse may make that amount look like a drop in the bucket.

Mark Cheffers, formerly of PricewaterhouseCoopers and now CEO of the Web site,, estimates that Andersen's exposures could be in the range of 10 to 100 times the firm's outside insurance coverage.

According to an article in Forbes Magazine, all of the Big Five firms participate in self-insurance programs to supplement their outside liability insurance. The total amount of Andersen's insurance arrangements is not known publicly. Should insurance claims exceed the firm's policies, exposure would ultimately fall on the shoulders of the firm's partners, who, under the terms of the limited liability partnership agreement, would face liability up to the amount of their equity in the firm.

Wait, there's more!
There's always more at AccountingWEB. We're an active community of financial professionals and journalists who strive to bring you valuable content every day. If you'd like, let us know your interests and we'll send you a few articles every week either in taxation, practice excellence, or just our most popular stories from that week. It's free to sign up and to be a part of our community.
Premium content is currently locked

Editor's Choice

As part of our continued effort to provide valuable resources and insight to our subscribers, we're conducting this brief survey to learn more about your personal experiences in the accounting profession. We will be giving away five $50 Amazon gift cards, and a $250 Amazon gift card to one lucky participant.
This is strictly for internal use and data will not be sold
or shared with any third parties.