Enron’s Lasting Influence
With the former Enron executives finally coming to trial, we are reminded again of the long shadow cast by the implosion of the company that helped enact the Sarbanes-Oxley (SOX) Act of 2002. Section 404 has added teeth to SOX, making regulation more expensive and staff intensive and the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) has been created to aid in the governance and enforcement of the accounting industry.
Audit committees have attained more important positions in corporate structures and are more attuned to avoid the conflicts of being both auditor and consultant for the same company. At the same time, with the collapse of Arthur Andersen, the consolidation of the Big Five to the Big Four now have four accounting firms doing the work for more than 90 percent of publicly traded companies, according to the New York Times.
“We certainly have seen some improvements in governance, but we’ve also seen some areas of no improvement, and some areas where things have gone backwards,” said Lynn E. Turner, speaking to the New York Times. Turner is the former chief accountant at the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and now managing director of research at Glass, Lewis & Company.
The outright accounting scandals of WorldCom, Tyco, and Adelphia have now morphed into companies making financial restatements. Glass, Lewis & Company reports that earnings restatements numbered 1,031 through the end of October 2005, compared with 650 for 2004 and 270 in 2001, according to the New York Times. John C. Coffee, speaking in the Los Angeles Times, said the restatements were not necessarily evidence of fraud but shows the tighter focus of accountants.
Also, more than 1,250 public companies, out of around 15,000 in total, reported material weaknesses in their internal corporate controls in October 2005. Some 232 other companies reported less serious, but significant deficiencies in their internal controls, according to the New York Times.
In contrast, a new study shows that the number of securities class-action suites has come down 17 percent in 2005. The 176 filed in 2005 is the lowest since 1997, according to Cornerstone Research and Stanford Law School. 1998 saw 239 suites, the highest number in recent years, according to the Los Angeles Times.
Christopher Cox, chairman of the SEC, said in a late December interview with the New York Times, that he agreed that more should be done, disclosing his intention to lead a commission effort to rewrite rules forcing companies to provide more financial details concerning executive pay.
Tighter accounting and disclosure rules enacted to enhance the transparency of financial information have lead to an industry-lead backlash. Cox said to the New York Times that it “would be a mistake” to retract major provisions of SOX.
“The shocks were so big that no director could miss the lesson and if they did miss somehow, the significant changes in the law made it absolutely certain that they are now more focused,” Cox added. “With just a few years of Sarbanes-Oxley under their belts, most companies are begrudgingly admitting that the exercise is producing benefits.”
SOX has sincere proponents though, institutional and pension investor groups being the most vocal. Alan G. Hevesi, New York comptroller of one of the nation’s largest institutional investors, has been leading the effort to increase corporate accountability. Speaking with the New York Times, Hevesi said, “We’ve had some successes in corporate governance reform. In other words – such as giving a greater voice to shareholders to elect independent directors and curbing excessive executive compensation – we haven’t been as successful. I worry about whether the necessary reforms have really been institutionalized.”
Executives say that restatements are healthy signs of change according to the New York Times although, “The general impression of the public is that accounting rules are black and white. They are often anything but that, and in many instances the changes in earnings came after new interpretations by the chief accountant of the S.E.C.," said Steve Odland, Office Depot’s CEO and head of a corporate governance task force at the Business Roundtable.
Accounting scandals are more often settled with the SEC or actions filed by the agency now. For example, McAfee, the Internet security company, has agreed to settle charges made by the SEC that they inflated revenues by some $622 million between 1998 and 2000. Their penalty will be $50 million. The settlement is awaiting court approval.
The SEC filed a civil lawsuit against six former executives then employed by an unnamed transfer-agent unit of Putnam Investments last week. They allegedly defrauded mutual funds and clients out of some $4 million in 2001. Also the judge has ruled that SEC testimony will be allowed into the trials of former Enron executives Jeffrey Skilling and Kenneth Lay.
Voice of the Editor
Which isn’t completely true. I mean, occasionally I drop by when I manage to sneak out of the nonstop frat party over at Going Concern, but I’m mostly a wallflower over there. I’m happy to say that I’ve been given express permission (or explicit orders, if you like) to wander over here to AccountingWEB more often.
Why is that, you might ask? My job is to replace the irreplaceable Gail Perry as Editor-in-Chief. What does that mean? I don’t really know! I think it’ll be fun getting a feel for things, throwing in my own thoughts here and there, and listening to the discussions you’re having about the accounting profession.