FEI files amicus curiae brief with Supreme Court in support of petition for review of Textron case
by AccountingWEB on
Financial Executives International (FEI) has filed an amicus curiae "friend of the court" brief with the Supreme Court of the United States in support of a petition for review of the U.S. vs. Textron case. FEI urged the Supreme Court to hear arguments in this significant case which concerns whether a public company can withhold from disclosure to the IRS tax accrual work papers that reflect the company's candid self-assessment of litigation hazards, and has been vocal on this issue during the course of this case. The outcome of this case has broad implications beyond the tax field and affects every public company.
The petition was submitted jointly by FEI's Committee on Taxation and Committee on Corporate Reporting and prepared by the law firm Miller & Chevalier. The Committees maintain that a 2007 lower court decision in favor of Textron appropriately balances the competing interests of the IRS, the investing public, and the fairness considerations that protect attorney work product. This appropriate balancing should permit companies to share candid assessments of potential litigation claims with their outside auditors, for example, without fear that such information would be accessible by competitors or adversaries. Unfortunately, the lower court decision was reversed by the en banc court of appeals and, accordingly, the Supreme Court is now being asked to weigh in on the issue.
A brief timeline of the case, along with FEI's actions are as follows:
- August 29, 2007 - The Federal District Court in Rhode Island held that the tax accrual work papers of Textron, Inc., (NYSE:TXT) based in Providence, RI, were protected by attorney work-product protection and denied the IRS access.
- April 4, 2008 - FEI's Tax Committee and Committee on Corporate Reporting filed an amicus curiae brief in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit in support of the District Court's decision.
- January 21, 2009 – A panel of the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the First Circuit issued its ruling, which affirmed the District Court's holding that Textron's internal tax accrual work papers are privileged material.
- March 25, 2009 – The First Circuit granted a motion for rehearing en banc and vacated the court's earlier opinion affirming the lower court.
- August 13, 2009 – The full First Circuit, by a 3-2 vote, held that Textron's tax accrual workpapers are not protected work product.
- December 24, 2009 – Textron filed a petition for certiorari seeking Supreme Court review of the First Circuit's decision.
- January 27, 2010 – FEI's Tax Committee and Committee on Corporate Reporting file amicus curiae brief with the Supreme Court of the United States in support of a petition for review of the case.
"The issues in the Textron case are extremely important to FEI's membership, and have a direct effect on all publicly held companies and their ability to prepare financial statements and efficiently file tax returns," said Matt Miller, FEI's Senior Director of Government Affairs. "We strongly encourage the Court to grant review in this case so that the Court can clarify the scope of work-product protection. We hope the Court will reach a decision that will allow companies to act in the best interest of their shareholders."
The Supreme Court is expected to act upon the Textron petition early this spring. A copy of the FEI brief is available upon request.
About Financial Executives International (FEI)
Financial Executives International (FEI) is an advocate for the views of corporate financial management. Its 15,000 members hold policy-making positions as chief financial officers, treasurers, and controllers. FEI enhances member professional development through peer networking, career planning services, conferences, publications, and special reports and research. Members participate in the activities of 85 chapters, 74 of which are in the United States and 11 in Canada.
You may like these other stories...
Anti Burger Kings: Seven US companies shrinking tax the old-fashioned wayBurger King’s decision to combine with Canadian donut shop Tim Hortons is renewing controversy over the lengths some US companies will go to...
Read more from Larry Perry here and in the Today's World of Audits archive.Since the AICPA's Financial Reporting Framework for Small- to Medium-sized Entities (FRF for SMEs) and some other financial reporting...
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has chosen a former partner and vice chairman with Deloitte LLP as its new chief accountant.James Schnurr, who specialized in financial and SEC reporting for public companies...
Upcoming CPE Webinars
Excel spreadsheets are often akin to the American Wild West, where users can input anything they want into any worksheet cell. Excel's Data Validation feature allows you to restrict user inputs to selected choices, but there are many nuances to the feature that often trip users up.
In this session we'll discuss the types of technologies and their uses in a small accounting firm office.
Transfer your knowledge and experience to prepare your team for the challenges and opportunities of an accounting career.
This webcast will include discussions of commonly-applicable Clarified Auditing Standards for audits of non-public, non-governmental entities.