Research Finds Internal Auditors Must Reach for New Heights or Risk Losing Relevance
by Terri Eyden on
By Frank Byrt
According to PricewaterhouseCooper's (PwC) 2013 State of the Internal Audit Profession Study issued March 18, uncertainty, volatility, and complexity are here to stay. And, as risks increase, internal audit's coverage of risk and performance is even more critical. However, many internal audit functions are not keeping pace, and companies are facing a major challenge in determining their strategy for internal audit and realizing value from their investment.
PwC surveyed about 1,100 chief audit executives and more than 630 stakeholders (CEOs, audit committee chairs, board members, and senior finance and risk managers) worldwide for the company's ninth annual survey on the role of internal auditors.
"Our survey shows that 80 percent of respondents believe threats are increasing, yet only 12 percent think their own organization manages risk extremely well," said Dean Simone, leader of PwC's Risk Assurance practice. "As risks increase, internal audit's coverage of risk and performance in emerging areas is critical, which provides internal audit with an ideal opportunity to demonstrate the value of the evolving profession. Internal audit must then aggressively increase its capabilities and add true value in risk areas most critical to the organization."
However, the survey found that even as companies plan to increase spending to add to their internal audit capabilities over the next eighteen month, those departments have not been keeping pace with their new duties. As a result, "companies face a major challenge in determining their strategy for internal audit and realizing value from their investment," the report says.
PwC's research identified three significant issues affecting many internal audit departments' ability to deliver more value:
- Management and board members are not aligned on their perception of internal audit's value and performance, and it appears as if board members may be settling for too little.
- The foundational capabilities of internal audit may not be strong enough to deliver today's work nor secure enough to build upon to generate greater value.
- Internal audit continues to struggle in maximizing the impact of its contribution, particularly in areas outside of its more traditional focus.
"Our research clearly indicates that internal audit must continue to evolve in its focus and significantly improve its performance – or risk losing relevance as other risk functions become more vital contributors to the organization's risk management," PwC warned in its report.
"Audit committees and management expect more from internal audit, providing a huge opportunity for internal audit functions to be relevant contributors to protecting stakeholder value and the business from the most critical risks," said Jason Pett, Internal Audit Services Leader for PwC.
Fifty-nine percent of those surveyed said the top focus on corporate spending will be on adding to data analytics capabilities; however, 54 percent said they would fill that capacity from reallocating resources within the company, rather than through new hires or hiring outside contractors.
"Technology has emerged as a key enabler for internal audit to improve audit quality and value while remaining cost-effective," the report said. "One of the fundamental ways internal audit can leverage technology is through data analytics."
The survey also found that 46 percent of the audit executives plan on building their company's general IT capabilities, and 63 percent said they would accomplish that through hiring or through outside vendors. Forty-one percent of those executives said they plan to beef up their IT security skills, and 71 percent said they expect to do that via new hires or contracting with third parties.
The survey of board members found that 79 percent think that internal audit contributes significant value, whereas only 44 percent of executive management felt the same way. At the same time, only 56 percent of the board members said that internal audit's performance was strong, compared to 37 percent of management.
"While this management view is far from positive, at least there is a relationship between perceived value and performance," the report said. "That is not the case with board members, who rated internal audit's value contribution high, yet rated its performance in core capabilities much lower, indicating they appear satisfied with average performance."
You may like these other stories...
The split over convergenceDavid M. Katz of CFO wrote an interesting article on Thursday about the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) backing away from their...
Read more from Larry Perry here and in the Today's World of Audits archive.Because of the importance of revenue recognition auditing procedures, and because of the breadth of the principles for the FRF for SMEs, this...
World Health Organization backs higher tobacco taxes to cut smokingThe World Health Organization (WHO) approved guidelines on Wednesday urging countries to increase cigarette taxes to help discourage smoking, wrote Martinne...