PCAOB Publishes 'Primer' for Audit Committees

By Christina Camara

Auditors often dismiss the importance of inspections by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), says its chairman, so the PCAOB is offering company audit committees some pointers about the inspection process in its twenty-six-page report -"Information for Audit Committees about the PCAOB Inspection Process." The report describes how PCAOB inspections of audit firms work and how to gather information from audit firms about those inspections.
 
On August 1, PCAOB Chairman, James Doty, told reporters that auditors explain away inspection findings as documentation problems, differences in professional judgments, or problems that have already been fixed. "The PCAOB would disagree with those characterizations, as report findings are serious matters," he said, according to Compliance Week.
 
The "primer" is designed to help audit committees learn more about the aspects of inspections that aren't public, in cases where the PCAOB is barred from discussing inspection findings. The board says firms can discuss the nonpublic inspection information, so audit committees should be skeptical if auditors say otherwise.
 
"We're aware that there's a range of practice with audit committees," Doty said. "That ranges from a high level of transparency and effectiveness to areas where we know it's not so effective."
 

PCAOB Suggestions

The PCAOB suggests that audit committees may want to ask their auditors:

  • Was the company's audit selected for PCAOB inspection?
  • Did the PCAOB identify deficiencies in other audits that involved auditing or accounting issues similar to issues presented in the company's audit?
  • What were the audit firm's responses to the PCAOB findings?
  • What topics are included in Part II findings?

 

Created by the Sarbanes-Oxley corporate reform legislation, the PCAOB has been inspecting audit firms since 2003. The legislation gave audit committees the authority to hire, fire, and oversee auditors, and it strengthened qualifications for serving on an audit committee.
 
"This is about empowering audit committees," Doty said. The inspection reports are the "only place where they (audit committees) can find independent evaluations of their auditors," he said.
 
One observer says CFOs should discuss issues with audit committees sooner. "They have an issue. They're not quite sure it's a problem so they don't want to tell you about it yet," Paula H. J. Cholmondeley, audit committee chair for Nationwide Mutual Funds, told CFO magazine. "That's one of the biggest areas of risk: when the audit committee doesn't find out about something until it's too late. The organization is too far into the issue." Regularly scheduled phone calls between the CFO and the audit committee would help, she said.
 
Related articles:
 

You may like these other stories...

Bank Leumi said to face $300 million demand in tax caseDavid Voreacos and Greg Farrell of Bloomberg reported on Wednesday that New York’s banking regulator will ask for more than $300 million to settle an investigation...
Deal to lock in US tax cuts is bubbling up on the HillSome US lawmakers are exploring a post-election deal that would lock in permanent tax cuts for major corporations and low-income families, Richard Rubin of Bloomberg...
Read more from Larry Perry here and in the Today's World of Audits archive.This article discusses basic accounting principles for operating expenses under the FRF for SMEs. Part 2 will address basic auditing procedures....

Already a member? log in here.

Upcoming CPE Webinars

Nov 5Join CPA thought leader and peer reviewer Rob Cameron and learn ways to improve the outcome of your peer reviews while maximizing the value of your engagement workflow.
Nov 18In this session Excel expert David Ringstrom, CPA tackles what to do when bad things happen to good spreadsheets.
Nov 19How do you minimize redundant work and unnecessary steps to maximize the amount of work moving through your firm?
Nov 20Kristen Rampe will share how to uncover new opportunities with your clients by asking powerful questions.