The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 continued its sweep through corporate America yesterday when the FBI arrested former Ernst & Young partner Thomas Trauger.
In one of the first document destruction cases brought under Sarbanes-Oxley, Trauger, 40, faces federal charges of obstructing an investigation by destroying or tampering with audit work papers. The audit in question involved the now-defunct NextCard Inc. of San Francisco and its bank subsidiary NextBank.
“This is one of the first cases in the country in which an auditor has been accused of destroying key documents in an effort to obstruct an investigation,” U.S. Attorney Kevin Ryan said in a statement.
The Securities and Exchange Commission brought unrelated charges against Trauger and Michael Mulligan, a former Ernst & Young audit manager. The SEC settled another matter with Oliver Flanagan, a former Ernst & Young senior manager.
Flanagan pled guilty to a criminal charge of obstructing the examination of a financial institution, according to a statement from the SEC, which settled its civil matter with him.
The SEC suit accused the three of tampering with Ernst & Young’s work papers from its 2000 NextCard audit when Trauger began to worry in November of 2001 about regulators inspectors the audit work, the SEC statement stated.
“Mr. Trauger, assisted by Mr. Flanagan, met in E&Y's offices in San Francisco and altered portions of the E&Y electronic working papers for the NextCard 2000 audit,” the SEC said in a statement. “Later in November 2001, Mr. Trauger asked Mssrs. Flanagan and Mullen to assist him in making additional alterations to the working papers.”
Reuters reported that attorneys for Trauger and Flanagan couldn’t be reached for comment. Mulligan’s attorney, Bob Breakstone, told Reuters that “Mike has cooperated with SEC and its investigation and voluntarily appeared with the SEC. We'll continue to cooperate. He has not been charged by federal prosecutors.”